Oura Ring 4 vs WHOOP 4.0
The definitive comparison for football players and teams. Why sleep tracking beats strain tracking—and our recommendation for programs that take recovery seriously.
Founder, Eyes Up
The Bottom Line
Our Recommendation for Football Players
Oura Ring, worn at night only. Take it off during practice and games. You don't want a ring on when you're catching footballs, blocking, or tackling. The ring is built for sleep tracking—and that's exactly what football players need.
Why Not WHOOP for Football?
WHOOP's strain tracking is designed for the general public who need to know “did I work out hard enough today?” College football players are always strained. They have 6 AM lifts, two-a-days, film sessions, and 70+ play games. The wristband tells them what they already know: they're exhausted. That data isn't actionable.
Sleep is the Only Controllable Variable
Football players can't reduce their strain—they have to show up to practice. But they can control their sleep. That's why sleep tracking matters and strain tracking doesn't. Coaches already have better strain data: film, play counts, big hits, and their own eyes. What they can't see is what happens when players go home at night.
Quick Comparison
| Feature | Oura Ring 4 | WHOOP 4.0 |
|---|---|---|
| Form Factor | Ring | Band |
| Sleep Tracking | Excellent | Very Good |
| Strain/Activity | Basic | Excellent |
| Recovery Score | Readiness Score | Recovery % |
| Heart Rate | Overnight + spot | 24/7 continuous |
| HRV Tracking | Overnight | 24/7 |
| Battery Life | 5-7 days | 4-5 days |
| Water Resistance | 100m | 10m |
| Display | None | None |
| Subscription Required |
Sleep Tracking
Sleep is where Oura shines. The ring uses a combination of infrared photoplethysmography (PPG), 3D accelerometer, and body temperature sensors to track your sleep stages with research-grade accuracy.
Oura Sleep Score
Combines time asleep, efficiency, restfulness, REM, deep sleep, latency, and timing into a 0-100 score. Validated against polysomnography.
WHOOP Sleep
Tracks sleep stages and sleep debt. Focus is on recovery optimization rather than sleep quality itself. Good but secondary to strain.
| Feature | Oura | WHOOP |
|---|---|---|
| Sleep Stage Accuracyvs polysomnography | 94% | ~80% |
| Body Temperature | ||
| Blood Oxygen (SpO2) | ||
| Sleep Latency | ||
| Circadian Rhythm | ||
| Nap Detection | ||
| Sleep Need Calculation |
Research Note
A 2023 study in Sleep Medicine found Oura Ring Gen 3 had 94% agreement with polysomnography for sleep staging—comparable to medical-grade devices. WHOOP has not published equivalent validation studies for sleep specifically.
Recovery & Readiness
Both devices give you a daily “how ready am I?” score, but they calculate it differently and present it for different use cases.
Oura Readiness Score
- Simple 0-100 score anyone can understand
- Factors in sleep, HRV, temperature, and previous activity
- Detects illness 1-2 days before symptoms appear
- Clear guidance: green/yellow/red days
- Doesn't account for real-time strain
- Can feel conservative (recommends rest often)
- No workout recommendations beyond "take it easy"
WHOOP Recovery Score
- Tied directly to strain recommendations
- Updates throughout the day with HRV
- Tells you exactly how hard you can train
- Journal feature links behaviors to recovery
- Can feel aggressive (always pushing)
- Recovery % can be confusing at first
- Less useful if you don't train daily
Illness Detection: The Hidden Value
Oura's temperature and HRV tracking can flag when a player is getting sick 24-48 hours before symptoms appear. In a football locker room, this is huge. One sick player can spread flu or COVID through the entire roster. Catching illness early means isolating players before they infect teammates—protecting your depth chart when it matters most.
For coaches: Oura's Readiness Score is easier to communicate across a roster. “Everyone above 70 is cleared for full practice” is a simpler rule than explaining strain budgets. WHOOP is better for individualized training load management.
Activity & Strain Tracking
This is WHOOP's home turf. WHOOP was built for athletes who want to optimize training load. But here's the question: does a football player need this?
| Feature | Oura | WHOOP |
|---|---|---|
| Strain/Load Score | Activity Score | Strain Score (0-21) |
| 24/7 Heart Rate | ||
| Real-time HR during workouts | No | Yes |
| Automatic workout detection | Basic | Excellent |
| Strain Coach | No | Yes |
| GPS | No | No (phone required) |
| Step counting | ||
| Calorie estimation | Good | Excellent |
The Football Reality
WHOOP wins every category here—but none of this matters for football players.
Strain tracking answers: “Did I work hard enough today?” A college football player running two-a-days doesn't need a wristband to answer that question. They're maxed out. Every day.
Coaches already have better strain data than any wearable: game film, practice reps, snap counts, big hits on tape. What they don't have visibility into is sleep. That's the gap worth filling.
Hardware & Comfort
Oura Ring 4
- Material: Titanium
- Weight: 3-5g (size dependent)
- Sizes: 4-15
- Finishes: Silver, Black, Brushed Silver, Stealth, Gold, Rose Gold
- Water Resistance: 100m
- Battery: Up to 8 days
- Charging: ~80 min to full
WHOOP 4.0
- Material: Polyurethane band
- Weight: ~27g (band)
- Sizes: One size, adjustable
- Accessories: Bicep, boxers, sports bra
- Water Resistance: 10m (IP68)
- Battery: 4-5 days
- Charging: Battery pack (no removal needed)
The Comfort Factor
Oura is virtually invisible. You forget you're wearing it. WHOOP is noticeable 24/7. For athletes who hate having things on their wrist during sleep, Oura is the clear choice. WHOOP counters with alternative wearing locations (bicep, clothing).
App Experience
| Feature | Oura App | WHOOP App |
|---|---|---|
| Design | Clean, simple | Data-dense, athlete-focused |
| Learning curve | Low | Moderate |
| Guided programs | ||
| Journal/tagging | Tags only | Full journal |
| Community features | None | Teams/Groups |
| Data export | ||
| Third-party integrations | Many | Many |
| AI insights | Basic | WHOOP Coach |
Oura's app prioritizes simplicity. You open it, see your scores, and move on. WHOOP's app assumes you want to dig into the data. Neither is wrong—it depends on how much time you want to spend analyzing your metrics.
Pricing & Value
| Feature | Oura Ring 4 | WHOOP 4.0 |
|---|---|---|
| Hardware Cost | $349 | $0 (included in subscription) |
| Monthly Fee | $6/mo ($70/yr) | $30/mo ($239/yr) |
| Year 1 Total | $419 | $239 |
| Year 2+ Total | $70 | $239 |
| 3-Year Total | $559 | $717 |
| Features without subscription | Basic scores only | Nothing (device stops) |
The Real Cost for Teams
For a 100-player roster over 3 years:
Oura: $34,900 (hardware) + $21,000 (subscriptions) = $55,900 total
WHOOP: $71,700 (subscriptions only, no hardware ownership)
Oura saves ~$16,000 over 3 years at scale—and you own the hardware.
For Football Teams
Here's how we recommend football programs think about wearables:
The EYES UP Protocol
- 1. Oura Ring for every player. It's the best sleep tracker, period.
- 2. Wear it at night only. Take it off for practice and games. You don't want titanium on your finger when catching a ball or throwing a punch in the trenches.
- 3. Ignore strain tracking. Your coaches have better data: film, snap counts, practice reps, and their own eyes. Wearables can't tell you anything about strain that coaches don't already know.
- 4. Focus on sleep scores. This is the one thing coaches can't see. It's the only recovery lever players control. Make it visible, make it cultural.
- 5. Use illness alerts. When Oura flags a player with elevated temperature or suppressed HRV, keep them away from the locker room. Protect your depth chart.
Why Oura for Football
- • Best-in-class sleep tracking accuracy (94% vs polysomnography)
- • Ring form factor—remove during practice, no grip interference
- • Illness detection protects locker room health
- • Simple sleep score everyone understands
- • No subscription required for core features
- • Lower cost at scale (100+ player rosters)
When WHOOP Makes Sense
- • Individual athletes training alone (not team sports)
- • Endurance sports where strain pacing matters
- • CrossFit, marathon, triathlon athletes
- • Players rehabbing injuries (tracking recovery load)
- • Off-season conditioning when volume is variable
- • Athletes who want to wear it 24/7 anyway
Ready to make sleep visible across your roster?
EYES UP turns Oura sleep scores into team-wide accountability. See who's recovering, who's struggling, and who might be getting sick—before it affects performance.
Learn MoreFrequently Asked Questions
Ready to take sleep seriously?
Whether you choose Oura, WHOOP, or both—the data only matters if you act on it. EYES UP helps teams turn sleep scores into cultural accountability.
Get in Touch